The Bitcoin center NYC is reviving the interest in Bitcoin in New York, and it is a pleasant surprise to see so many people interested in this debate. This Bitcoin debate was held on Tuesday, February 18th 2014 at the Bitcoin Center on 40 Broad Street in New York, very close to the New York Stock Exchange. The previous day, they hosted a trading and networking event, with Jeffrey Tucker ringing the trading bell and some old-school style pit-trading.
Although this was technically a debate, it seemed more of a conversation about money, economics, government, banking and Bitcoin. Andrew Schiff said he has more favorable views of Bitcoin than his brother Peter Schiff, the famed investment broker who correctly predicted the housing crash and subsequent financial crisis. Peter Schiff remains bearish on USD and the economy in general and bullish on commodities, but not Bitcoin. He thinks Bitcoin isn’t going anywhere and used the awful Tulip Mania analogy to describe Bitcoin in the past. Andrew Schiff said he has milder views about Bitcoin.
The Bitcoin center was packed, but luckily the center is fairly large in space with adequate standing room.
The major points raised by Andrew Schiff against the popularity of Bitcoin were that it doesn’t have a long history in the marketplace like gold does (fair enough, but you can’t really change that now, can you?) He also believes that a limited supply and anonymity are the major factors contributing to the value of Bitcoin, and if either one of these is compromised, then the value of Bitcoin might not hold. He essentially held the view that we just don’t know where Bitcion might be headed.
Both the panelists got some time to present their point of view, then debated a bit between themselves and then there was a question-answer round from Twitter and the audience.
The audience knew their stuff, and there was a good discussion that followed most questions, from zerocoin to Bitcoin in Africa. One question about mining gold from asteroids got the audience and panelists laughing and dismissing the question that I thought was totally fair – it’s not that the private sector isn’t trying already.
The debate lasted about an hour and a half, and the audience was pretty keen on listening in, which is always a good sign. Not surprisingly, Jeffrey Tucker seemed more of a crowd favorite than Andrew Schiff.
The final remarks were made by Nick Spanos, the founder of the New York Bitcoin center. There are lots of events happening here, so if you’re in or around New York, don’t forget to attend some of them at least.
We’ve also been promised that the live recording will be available soon, although I couldn’t really find where. I’ll update the post if/when I find the full video. They definitely did record the whole show, which is a great sign of things to come!
As a final note, kudos to the guy who attended this event with this on – yes, we all know Bitcoin is the honey badger of money, and Jeffrey Tucker actually referred to this during his talk too!
Bitcoin is a lot of things to a lot of people. When the price speculation is at its peak, it seems like New York with its financial industry takes the lead. When startups around Bitcoin are in the news, Silicon Valley, California, takes the lead with its brilliant startup ecosystem. When philosophical and economical side of things escalate, libertarian heartlands like Atlanta are in the news. Of late, it seemed like New York was not as active on the Bitcoin scene and the center seemed to be shifting to California. Not anymore.
The Bitcoin Center in New York is located on 40 Broad Street, in the heart of the financial district in Manhattan. I was pleasantly surprised by the number of people in attendance today for a Bitcoin-pit style trading and networking event. There were more than 100 people in attendance at the small space, and the chief guest was Jeffrey Tucker, a well known libertarian and Bitcoin supporter and the founder of Liberty.me.
Whenever Jeffrey Tucker is at an event, it invariably leads to a good group of libertarians. There were many in the crowd who didn’t know much about Bitcoin but cared deeply about libertarian principles, both economic and political. Also, expectedly, there were quite a few people from Students for Liberty.
There was of course, the media (like yours truly) and there was NHK World Japan, a broadcasting company. Should be interesting to see what they come up with.
On the altcoin side of things, Florincoin was giving away free Flourincoin t-shirts during the event. That’s a smart move by the team, and other altcoins should take note. Now that there’s a deluge of new altcoins, teams should do everything to stand out from the crowd and in-person events are a great way to introduce people to your coin.
There was Coinstax selling beautiful 1oz silver coins (Walking Liberty Silver Dollar, Silver Buffalo, Chinese Panda, etc.) and bars at very reasonable prices for Bitcoin. There were a few gold items as well. It’s good to be able to spend your Bitcoins on items that you want.
There was demonstration of another Bitcoin/Dogecoin ATM that only provide the hardware. This will always be tricky in the US due to KYC/AML laws but hopefully when the legal and regulatory environment is cleared, Bitcoin ATMs will be commonplace here (and what better city than New York for this!)
All in all, a great Bitcoin event in New York and hope there are many more in the future.
The first global Bitcoin conference in India took place on December 14th and 15th in Bangalore, India. BTC Geek was invited as a media outlet to the event and we were very happy to be a part of a growing Bitcoin community in India. There were several things that stood out in the conference from our perspective, so I’ll list all of them here –
Bitcoin is still in nascent stages in India: Not a lot of people who attended the conference seemed to know a lot about Bitcoin, in contrast to some of the other Bitcoin conference, such as the Inside Bitcoin conference in Las Vegas that we were also a part of.
There is a lot of enthusiasm: There is a lot of enthusiasm from everyone – from the tech crowd to the traders to the dabblers. The people who attended the conference weren’t limited to just the geeks or libertarians or traders, as can often happen with such conferences. There was a good mix of people from very different backgrounds.
The talks were basic and informative: This was keeping with the audience, I guess.
The conference was expensive: By average Indian standards, the conference was quite expensive, although there were discounts if you had registered earlier. The reason I mention this is because even though the passes were quite expensive, there were still a lot of people who attended. The final price for the passes was Rs. 17,000 for the two day event, about $275.
Lots of entrepreneurs and bankers: There were lots of entrepreneurs and bankers, although the bankers were not present in any official capacity. It seems that Bitcoin has successfully piqued the interest of many folks in India!
Not focused only on trading: This was refreshing – even though Bitcoin is at a very nascent stage in India, it seemed that the interest was coming from many different sides of Bitcoin, not just trading, as happened in China. There were a lot of entrepreneurs in the crowd working on Bitcoin related merchant payments, for example.
Unocoin launched: Unocoin officially launched at the conference, which would be a way to buy Bitcoin with your Indian Rupees. This joins BuySellBitcoin in doing the same.
The whole Bitcoin ecosystem is still at an early development stage, but it was good to see a lot of interest and enthusiasm. India can become a successful Bitcoin market for a number of reasons – high inflation, world’s biggest remittance market, good software workforce, etc. Even though Bitcoin is off to a slow start, the interest seems to be steadily on the rise. The recent comments about Bitcoin in the Indian news media is only helping, and the government has, even recently, said that it will keep away from trying to regulate Bitcoin.
Speakers:
What do you think about the potential of Bitcoin in India?
We’ll be there at the Inside Bitcoin conference in Las Vegas, on 10th and 11th December 2013. It has an impressive line-up of speakers and should be a very good experience. There are lots of interesting people in the Bitcoin world attending, and we hope the cover the event.
To get updates, follow us on Twitter @BTCGeek. The official hashtag for the event is #Bitcoinconf
If you’re going to this conference as well, drop us a line!
The first Bitcoin conference in India is going to take place on December 14th and 15th in the city of Bangalore, the 5th largest city in India and home to most of the multi-national software companies in India. This should be an interesting conference for those in India and people in the Bitcoin space in general.
Bitcoin exploded in China in the last two months, thanks to a number of factors. However, India, the second most populous country after China, also holds a lot of potential for Bitcoin, although the news out of the country has been pretty slow of late. I wrote an article back in August, Will Bitcoin Take Off in India and points I highlighted still hold true. Although India would probably not see as much trading frenzy as China, it has a very skilled software workforce that can actually contribute to the platform of Bitcoin itself, which is much more important than just the price vs. USD.
Bitcoin has several benefits it can offer to consumers and businesses in India, and conferences like these will only help spread the word and bring awareness in the community. It is also a very good way to go meet the people who are working on Bitcoin and related ideas in person, so you can be a part of the community as well. It is still in a nascent stage, and so getting in on the ground floor of the development should be a good start. I think come next year, there will be more such conferences in India – it’s too big a market to ignore Bitcoin completely.
BTC Geek is also happy to announce that we’ll have one of our team members go and cover this event, so we’ll publish a detailed blog post about the conference once it ends and also tweet during the event. You can follow us on Twitter @BTCGeek to stay updated on the conference details.
Drop us a line if you’re attending this conference.
Speakers: Jeffrey Tucker, Doug French, Cathy Reisenwitz, Tuur Demeester, Daniel Krawisz, Michael Goldstean, Stephan Kinsella, Peter Surda, Tony Gallippi, Stephen Pair, Charlie Shrem, Charles Hoskinson, Daniel Larimer, Adam B. Levine
Online Event: Get your video passes at LetsTalkBitcoin. They will also release free Youtube videos of the event later on.
What an event it has been! A day full of great speakers and great ideas. Some were the usual suspects – libertarian philosophies, anarchy believers and people who want you to really think about money. There were some new revelations – Invictus Innovations is working on amazing things that again has the potential to do a lot of good things and promises to be a one-stop-shop for decentralizing the heck out of everything. For the first time, we got to saw the Lamassu Bitcoin ATM in action.
This conference was different from other Bitcoin conferences like the San Jose 2013 Bitcoin conference in that this was much more focused towards the libertarian philosophies that attracted some early adopters rather than the technical aspects of Bitcoin. This was more of a ‘high-level’ overview of Bitcoin and its philosophies and had a heavy dose of libertarian-anarchist speakers and crowd. However, there was ample time for the Bitcoin entrepreneurs to talk to the audience and it did attract a lot of important people in the Bitcoin community. Sometime it is good to keep the bigger picture in mind that most likely Satoshi Nakamoto had in mind when he designed the currency in the first place.
It was still a great meeting place to meet other Bitcoin enthusiasts and entrepreneurs. Jeffrey Tucker was the main event moderator. I’ll cover the individual talks in more detail in later follow up posts. Here are the event highlights.
Also, another note – none of the panel discussions were really panel discussions. Instead, they were short speeches from the speakers.
Jeffrey Tucker kicking off the Crypto Currency Conference 2013 in Atlanta
The event started off with Jeffrey Tucker introducing the conference and Bitcoin to the audience with a welcome address about Bitcoin, titled “A New Currency for the Digital Age”.
Then the first panel that consisted of three speakers, each of them giving a short speech about their topic. The panel was titled “Money and Freedom” and moderated by Jeffrey Tucker.
Doug French, the libertarian economist talking about the banking sector
Doug French is a libertarian economist and former president of the Mises Institute, so no surprise there when he gave a speech titled “The Decline and Fall of Conventional Banking and the Rise of the New”. It was a riveting talk and he covered a lot of good points. He talked about the fiat system and banking and how when you deposit money in the bank, you’re not really “depositing” but rather “lending” that money to the bank. There were good moments and Doug French could make the audience and panelists laugh.
Doug French makes the panelists laugh
This was followed by Cathy Reisenwitz’s talk titled “Why a Free Society Needs a Free Money”
Cathy Reisenwitz on stage
Tuur Demeester gave a very good an interesting talk titled “Bitcoin and the End of Collectivism”. I would recommend watching his talk when it comes out.
Tuur Demeester at the Crypto Currency Conference
Lots of interesting ideas and I’ll be writing more about those on my blog later.
Tuur’s talk
That was it from the first panel, followed by Q&A. There were intelligent points raised. For instance, in response to one of the comments of Doug French, when he mentioned that Bitcoin cannot be duplicated, a random intelligent guy in the crowd corrected, “Bitcoin can be owned by multiple people but can be spent only by one” which is an important distinction because it allows you to create multiple copies of your Bitcoin for safekeeping, which means seizing Bitcoins is very different from seizing fiat – if someone manages to steal your private key, they will need to transfer that money out of your wallet, because otherwise someone else can spend it. This can also work as an insurance system where the events leading up to a seizure might mean the transfer of Bitcoin from that wallet (either through an Oracle or through an agent).
The second panel, again moderated by Jeffrey Tucker, had a couple of people, again from the libertarian breed rather than the technical people or entrepreneurs who actually “get” Bitcoin. These were again interesting nonetheless.
Daniel Krawisz spoke about “Why Libertarians Should Understand Cryptography” and Michael Goldstein talked about “Bitcoin Beyond Money”.
Just before lunch, Stephen Kinsella spoke about “The History, Meaning and Future of Legal Tender” and covered, from a legal perspective, all about legal tender laws and how it’s applicable to the Bitcoin community. He has interesting insights into what the governments could do to try to devalue Bitcoin, e.g. using the Greesham’s Law to create ‘bad money’ that then drives out ‘good money’ aka Bitcoin out of circulation. He had a good understanding of the past and what the future might hold for something as new as Bitcoin.
After lunch, Peter Surda talked about “Bitcoin is Sound Money”. This was followed by the ‘Merchantcraft’ panel that consisted of Tony Gallippi, Stephen Pair and Charlie Shrem and moderated by Adam B. Levine of Lets Talk Bitcoin. Tony Gallippi, the CEO of BitPay talked about “Bitcoin Entrepreneurship”. Stephen Pair talked about “The Technological Evolution of Money”.
Merchantcraft panel
Charlie Shrem started off with giving an update of his now vanished service BitInstant by letting the audience know that they are coming back, after being hit by a class action lawsuit and handling the whole thing pretty badly. Aptly, his talk was “Growing Pains: Taking a Bitcoin Startup to the Next Level”. Charlie Shrem is planning on reviving the BitInstant. It would be interesting to see how many people come back and trust the site again, now that there are several alternatives that are very good and have proven to be more reliable.
The next panel was Future Development, dominated by Charles Hoskinson and Daniel Larimer of Invictus Innovations who unveiled their BitShares project along with the Keyhotee project for identities. The BitShares project, as promising as it seems by tracking prices based on a prediction system, needs to prove its worth in the real world. The beta is slated for December 2013 and it would be interesting to watch it grow and progress. Charles ended with a mention of a mysterious hardware device that will be coming soon but didn’t provide any more details.
Charles Hoskinson introducing the BitShares idea
Charles Hoskinson talked about “A New Approach to BTC Exchanges” and introduced the BitShares ideas and Daniel Larimer talked about “Decentralized Solutions to Centralized Problems” introducing the Keyhotee identity system and a plan for decentralized, secure communication including text and voice.
Daniel Larimer introducing the Keyhotee identity system
Adam B. Levine of Lets Talk Bitcoin gave a speech “Doing Business with a Rising-Value Currency” where he mentioned that he does and expects at least a 25-30% discount when the asking is done in Bitcoin rather than fiat. This is to compensate for the fact that the currency value will probably rise for Bitcoin and fall for fiat, and Bitcoin transactions also have other advantages like no charge-backs and little to no fees.
Adam B. Levine of Lets Talk Bitcoin
The event was wrapped up with Austin and Becky Craig, the so called ‘Bitcoin couple’ who are trying to live only on Bitcoin for 90 days after getting married and making a documentary at the same time.
Austin and Becky Craig, the so-called Bitcoin couple
This was wrapped up with cocktails and networking among the crowd. It was an interesting mix of people overall, from libertarians to entrepreneurs. I’ll write more about the individual talks in later detailed posts.
The cryptocurrency conference in Atlanta begins in Atlanta today. I’ll be blogging about it, and introducing you to some interesting people and speakers, so keep an eye out.
The conference has a lot of interesting talks from a lot of interesting people. If you’re unable to attend, you should get a video pass, so you can watch the talks. I’ll be discussing the talks in more detail as and when they unfold.
Jeffrey Tucker is scheduled to start off the conference with a talk “A New Currency for the Digital Age” followed by a panel discussion on money and freedom. There are talks and panel discussions throughout the day. Towards the end, Austin and Becky Craig are going to talk about Life on Bitcoin which should be interesting. There’s a cocktail reception from 5pm-7pm to wrap things up.